Compare and Contrast 2nd Grade Unit

This three-lesson unit includes identifying compare and contrast key words, using compare and contrast key words, and comparing and contrasting fairy tales. Texts used include a short downloadable/printable narrative text; Stellaluna, by Janell Cannon; and Cinder Edna, by Ellen Jackson. All lessons include opportunities for direct teaching, guided practice, and independent practice. The included printable materials are excellent. You will need to register for the site in order to access them, but registration is free.

Weblink address (URL):

Standards & Objectives

Learning objectives:

Learning Goal:

Identify similarities and differences using key words.
Use key words to compare and contrast two objects.
Use key words to compare and contrast two fairy tales.

Lesson Variations

Blooms taxonomy level:

Understanding

Differentiation suggestions:

Lesson 1 Tips:

Try brainstorming a list of clue words with students before the Direct Teaching. Students would most likely be able to identify: same, different, and alike.
For students that need additional scaffolding, consider starting with sample sentences before moving onto paragraph reading.

Lesson 2 Tip:

Provide visual scaffolding by displaying compare and contrast key words in a prominent place in the classroom. This will remind students to use these words in their reading as well when they complete the Independent Practice.

Lesson 3 Tips:

Support students by providing a book or movie of Cinderella to remind them of the story before comparing and contrasting to Cinder Edna. Disney’s Cinderella is a great resource.

Helpful Hints

Necessary Materials:

Provided:

“My Brother and I” Passage
Example T-Chart
“Moving to a New Town” Independent Practice Passage
Independent Practice Worksheet
Example Chart

Not Provided:

Markers
Chart paper
Stellaluna by Janell Cannon
Lined paper

References

Contributors:

Kathryn Pattullo

Originator:

Ayers Institute for Learning & Innovation